Sony released its innovative Lens Style cameras last year as a response to the increasing popularity of photography performed with smartphones. The QX series consists of lenses that feature the sensor and all the necessary technology to constitute a “proper” camera. What they lack is a traditional grip and an LCD screen but that’s where your smartphone comes into play. By connecting the two devices with Wifi or NFC technology, your smartphone enables you to control everything on screen, from the adjustments of settings to image taking.
While I found the concept interesting and a fresh addition to the market, the idea of having to connect two devices every time I want to take a picture doesn’t really appeal to me. People that take shots with their smartphones do it fast when they see something interesting and they most likely want to share it right away. It’s about moments more than anything else. But when Sony announced the QX1 with its interchangeable capabilities, I was really surprised.
Connecting a lens camera to your smartphone is one thing, but connecting a sensor with a mount that can host proper MILC lenses pushes the boundaries even further. Can it really work?
An APS-C system for your mobile device
The QX1 has a 20 megapixel APS-C sensor (the same as the Sony a5000) and features the same E-mount found on Sony mirrorless cameras. It features 25 AF points with contrast detection, continuous shooting of 10fps, an ISO sensitivity of 100-16000 and the Bionz X image processor. It even includes a built-in popup flash. Video can be recorded in AVCHD format up to 30p. You can use the same SD cards that you use on you regular camera and shoot RAW and JPG. Basically, you have the same specs and features of a regular Sony camera.
The QX1 is the first lens style camera to feature such a large sensor. The other models have smaller sensors, such as the QX100 which has the same 1 inch sensor found on the RX100 mark II.
Ergonomics and functionality
Depending on the kind of mobile device you own, connecting the two products together can be a little bit tricky. I own an iPhone which doesn’t include NFC technology. NFC allows you to connect two devices by simply touching them together. With the iPhone, you have to use Wifi which requires you to turn on the camera, go to the Wifi settings on your smartphone, access the lens style camera network, enter the password, then open the dedicated app (Sony PlayMemories). It is only then you can finally see the live view image on your phone screen and start to take pictures.
A smaller version of the JPGs (2mp) is automatically transferred to the iPhone photo library. Of course if you use an SD card inside the Lens Style camera, you can access the full-sized JPGs and RAW files later. It is not possibile to transfer RAW files directly to the iOS device but apparently it is possible with Android devices. And if you want to use it right away as a way of sharing something on Facebook, you don’t really need RAW anyway.
As with the other QX models, the QX1 has a built-in mechanism to attach the camera to the body of the smartphone. You can also use it separate from the phone, which is useful for selfies for example.
The operations are quite simple. You can take pictures by touching the dedicated virtual button on the screen or using the shutter button on the lens. The autofocus works well and you can change the focus point on your smartphone screen, which is useful and fun to play with. On the iPhone you can also change the most important settings like the shooting mode, aperture, shutter speed, ISO etc. The first lens I tried was the 16-50mm F/3.5-5.6 OSS motorised kit zoom lens. You can control the focal length either with the zoom button on the lens or via your touch screen. Once you take a photo, it only takes a short time to upload it to the smartphone.
Image quality and lenses
In this case talking about image quality is a little bit redundant. Certainly it is an APS-C sensor and a very good one at that, so the performance far outdoes that of any photo capabilities built into a mobile device.
But what I was interested in was to use another lens on the QX1, so I mounted my 55mm f/1.8 FE, which became a portrait lens on the QX1 APS-C sensor. As you can see from the photo below, the combo becomes more prominent. While the QX1 grip remained attached to my iPhone 5s, I felt that the whole combo was too fragile to carry around if I didn’t keep it steady with both hands.
I admit that it was fun to take some shots with the 55mm but I couldn’t see myself swapping lenses on the QX1 on a regular basis, let alone using something bigger than a kit or pancake lens.
Conclusion
While I think that the QX10, QX30 and even the QX100 are interesting accessories to the smart photography, I find the QX1 concept too drastic to be practical. I respect Sony’s desire to shake the market and put innovative products out there that give users an alternative but at the same time, one of the key things about taking a shot with a smartphone is its simplicity. You don’t care about exposure, shutter speed, ISO or any of the other settings. You just compose and take the shot. Having to mount a lens camera or an interchangeable lens complicates the process and if you want a better tool to take photographs, you may as well just buy a proper camera. Furthermore, most new camera models now include Wifi or NFC to share high quality images when you want to. Experimentation and new technology aside, I really don’t see a reason to own a QX1.
Hi Simon and thanks for sharing your experience. I agree that it can be a good choice for someone that doesn’t want to carry a camera but want to take better pictures with his smartphone. But if your interest with photography increases you might consider a proper camera in the future. For me it’s just works better with the overall ergonomics etc. Also today there are very good compact cameras capable of great image quality. Look at the Sony RX100 series for example.
Just for the record I own a qx100, so the first generation of these. I’ve found it to be really fun….
My situation is that I’m often traveling or on a bike somewhere, so lugging around a dslr isnt a serious option. This represents a compromise, and the Smartphone faff can be annoying, so not a perfect compromise, but there are two reasons why I still use the qx100.
1) If, per chance I end up taking a great photo of my friends or girlfriend in a beautiful place in the swiss Alps – I want to be able to make it big, get it printed in canvas and hung on my wall. I don’t do this often, clearly… But with a smartphone camera that’s not possible at all… Perhaps I could carry a smaller point and shoot… But then I have a second device anyway.
Also, once you’ve seen the difference between a smartphone and the sharpness of a better lens / sensor, you sort of don’t want to go back.
2) my girlfriend introduced me to playing with photography – light and aperture and shutter speeds. I don’t think that sort of flexibility is commonly available on point and shoot… So suddenly you’re looking at something bigger, which I’m not lugging around the mountains unless you’re doing it for me :-).
In a way for me, the qx100 sparked an amateur interest in photography. I Bought it for reason 1, but started playing with it for reason two… I went backpacking for 8 weeks and spent some time playing with shutter speeds around waterfalls. There is no way I would have carried the dslr to make that possible…
I’m seriously considering either of the next versions… But I’d take advice on different kit too…
I find this concept interesting and I am thinking to join. I have an old DSLR and it is often too heavy to carry all the day. This Sony QX is flexible and easy to use with my smartphone which I carry with me all the time. So many times I was disappointed by the quality of the smartphone’s pictures. So this would be a welcome step up in flexibility. Those who bought in to a system already, I understand that it is obsolete for them.
Actually it is the only e-mount lens I own 🙂
Your FE 55 1.8? I guess I didn’t realize you had bought into the E-mount system!
I guess it sounds a useful option and some smartphone users might think it would be a way to get their phone to take higher quality images. But I remember seeing videos of how difficult the first version of this was to use and though this model is hopefully an improvement, it seems it’s still somewhat of a pain to use.
As you rightly point out, it’s somewhat easier to use a dedicated camera and it does take away much of the convenience and instant reactive ease of using a phone to take pictures.
Pretty much in the ‘Look what we can make’ category. The Panasonic 1” sensor phone and the Samsung K phone with it’s zoom lens seem to me to be a much more productive way to go.
It’s not as though I could use it anyway, I have a Nokia 1020 which is a Windows phone and a Blackberry, neither of which it will work with.
Sony says that the demands are higher than expected but it is also related on how much they planned to sell those products in the first place. It doesn’t mean that everyone want to buy one.
The phone will always give priority to calls so probably the app will stop working until the call is finished. But it could create more issues maybe like the need to connect again to the device etc.
Its the start of a modular approach to cameras , but not a very practical one. As you say in your report, most people who use cameras in their phones are not that interested in the technical side. And what happens if you receive a phone call while the lens module is strapped to your phone !!! Now that would be interesting.
Your conclusion is spot on I think. And if there is a huge demand for this, then they are welcome to it. Personally, from all the reports of this thing, it sounds like using it is a punishment rather than a pleasure!!
Yes I know apparently they are selling really well. I don’t dislike the concept of the QX cameras, I just think that the QX1 is a bit too much. Sony says that the QX1 is for advanced users. It looks like they truing to create a niche for this kind of products.
According to another site Sony reports that they have a big backorder list on this type of lens because they didn’t expect such a high demand 🙂 …
I could imagine, that it could serve some purposes: For the smartphone minded, but also for some other purposes such as putting it on a pole using it for Panorama photography.
However I think of it as cumbersome in order to to take photos to synch it with my smartphone 1st … so I decided against and will continue using a more conventional camera body to do my panos … nevertheless one has to respect the innovation efforts Sony was doing recently … never would have thought I’d have spent a look at a Sony cam …